Democracy and human rights Quote by Cherian George

“Of all the attempts to propel Singapore faster along the path of political liberalisation, few have backfired as badly as the West's push for democracy and human rights” quote by Cherian George — Download Open image

““Of all the attempts to propel Singapore faster along the path of political liberalisation, few have backfired as badly as the West's push for democracy and human rights””

Cherian George

About This Quote

The attempt to accelerate Singapore's political liberalization by imposing Western democratic ideals has backfired, causing more problems than progress.

In simple terms: Western democracy push harmed Singapore.

Key Takeaway

Avoid imposing external political models.

Themes

politics culture international relations

Mood

cautious analytical

Type

political strategic

When to use this quote

policy making
foreign aid
NGO advocacy

Key Concepts

democracy promotion political reform cultural clash

Questions to Reflect On

Should reforms be tailored to local culture?
What are the risks of external political pressure?

A Different Perspective

Western models may not fit local contexts.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4.9 out of 5 (10 ratings)

More by Cherian George

“But the habit of framing issues in terms of Asian and Western values did distort Singapore's view of its own challenges. Policy-makers looking through…

Cherian George

Image

“Since the mid-1980s, the government had sensed that one key reason why the opposition-for-opposition's-sake argument was so compelling to voters was that the did…

Cherian George

Image

“Certainly, the PAP applies far more stringent background checks on its candidates than the opposition does on its own. However, in some respects, a…

Cherian George

Image

“Singapore's tragedy is not the absence of idealism, but that it systematically rewards the individualistic majority and discourages the socially-conscious minority. This is at…

Cherian George

Image

“The Singapore School's quarrel with the West was partly over the sequence and pace of democratisation. It was acknowledge that certain norms originating in…

Cherian George

Image

“We are told that the main risk factors threatening Singapore's peace and prosperity are, first, our own unreliability as citizens (we may succumb to…

Cherian George

Image

“The answer lies in a system of press management combining watertight legal controls with a compelling political ideology that encourages not just obedience, but…

Cherian George

Image

“The Singapore School of Thought, as some began to call it, emphasised the lack of universality of many Western political norms...Singapore's own view emphasised…

Cherian George

Image

“The leaders' adherence to the principle of collective cabinet responsibility makes it difficult to ascertain the respective contributions of each, but enough is known…

Cherian George

Image

“As the state spreads it tentacles into every corner of life in the name of regulation, rationalization or economic development, people who wanted their…

Cherian George

Image

“The main rationale for the "elimination of politics' is also its main tool: rapid and broad-based economic development, in PAP thinking, both justifies as…

Cherian George

Image

“Equally important was the question of whose road map to follow. No country should be expected to arrive at exactly the same destination as…

Cherian George

Image

“And, if even a polished, professional communicator like Catherine Lim misfired in her attempt, what chance did most Singaporeans have? That affair remained a…

Cherian George

Image

“Not everyone would see a passive public as necessarily a bad thing. There are benefits to limiting political engagement to a minority of highly…

Cherian George

Image

“Perhaps, like bureaucracies everywhere, government officials in Singapore are uncomfortable with groups who appeal successfully to the public's sense of idealism, and whose work…

Cherian George

Image

Explore all 20 Cherian George quotes

More Democracy and human rights quotes

There are degrees of incompatibility, and there are more factors relevant to upholding democracy and human rights than the operation of neoliberal markets. Perhaps…

Richard A. Falk

Image

Standing with Israel - for democracy and human rights - will always be an issue of right versus wrong.

Brian Mast

Image

For all freedom-loving Americans, standing with Israel - for democracy and human rights - will always be an issue of right versus wrong.

Brian Mast

Image

“As long as the United States remains a democracy, I want to be in the ideological fight against illiberal nationalism and continue to make…

Michael McFaul

Image

I believe that American engagement, through our embassy, our businesses, and most of all through our people, is the best way to advance our…

Chris Christie

Image

We must struggle for creating a democratic system that is dedicated to democracy and human rights.

Akbar Ganji

Image

Education is important even beyond the bounds of the opportunities it gives to the individual; it is a crucial and basic requirement for ensuring…

Sadiq Khan

Image

There is always an element of realpolitik that has to be present in the conduct of any nation's national security affairs. At the same…

John McCain

Image

We don't know yet how to build a society which is environmentally sustainable, which is shareable with everybody on the planet, which promotes stability…

Alex Steffen