Military service Quote by Bertrand Russell
““What would have happened if Einstein had advanced something equally new in the sphere of religion or politics? English people would have found elements of Prussianism in his theory; anti-Semites would have regarded it as a Zionist plot; nationalists in all countries would have found it tainted with lily-livered pacifism, and proclaimed it a mere dodge for escaping military service. All the old-fashioned professors would have approached Scotland Yard to get the importation of his writings prohibited. Teachers favourable to him would have been dismissed. He, meantime, would have captured the Government of some backward country, where it would have become illegal to teach anything except his doctrine, which would have grown into a mysterious dogma not understood by anybody. Ultimately the truth or falsehood of his doctrine would be decided on the battlefield, without the collection of any fresh evidence for or against it. This method is the logical outcome of William James’s will to believe.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: "The Will to Believe", 1912
He sat that if Einstein had proposed new ideas in religion or politics, society would politic politicize and weaponize them, showing how groundbreaking work faces ideological distortion.
In simple terms: Innovative ideas are often twisted by political and religious biases.
Beware of bias when evaluating new theories.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- academic discourse
- public policy
- media coverage
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How do biases shape scientific acceptance?
- Can we separate ideas from their proponents?
The argument assumes all societies react uniformly, ignoring cultural nuances.