Animal kingdom Quote by Arthur Schopenhauer
““[Materialism] seeks the primary and most simple state of matter, and then tries to develop all the others from it; ascending from mere mechanism, to chemism, to polarity, to the vegetable and to the animal kingdom. And if we suppose this to have been done, the last link in the chain would be animal sensibility - that is knowledge - which would consequently now appear as a mere modification or state of matter produced by causality. Now if we had followed materialism thus far with clear ideas, when we reached its highest point we would suddenly be seized with a fit of the inextinguishable laughter of the Olympians. As if waking from a dream, we would all at once become aware that its final result - knowledge, which it reached so laboriously, was presupposed as the indispensable condition of its very starting-point, mere matter; and when we imagined that we thought matter, we really thought only the subject that perceives matter; the eye that sees it, the hand that feels it, the understanding that knows it. Thus the tremendous petitio principii reveals itself unexpectedly.””
About This Quote
Materialism reduces consciousness to a mere by of matter, but this leads to a circular argument where knowledge presupposes the very material basis it claims to explain.
In simple terms: Materialism's logical flaw
Knowledge cannot be derived solely from matter
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- debating the nature of consciousness
- critiquing scientific reductionism
- teaching philosophy of mind
- writing about epistemic foundations
Key Concepts
Practical Applications
- philosophical analysis
- critical essays
Questions to Reflect On
- Is consciousness reducible to physical processes?
- How does materialism address the origin of perception?