Skip to content

Bernard-of-clairvaux Quote by Alison Weir

“After the dedication, Eleanor saw Bernard privately, probably at her own request. He came prepared to offer more spiritual comfort, thinking that she too might be suffering qualms of conscience over Vitry, but he was surprised to learn that she was not. Nevertheless, several matters were indeed…” quote by Alison Weir
Download Open image
““After the dedication, Eleanor saw Bernard privately, probably at her own request. He came prepared to offer more spiritual comfort, thinking that she too might be suffering qualms of conscience over Vitry, but he was surprised to learn that she was not. Nevertheless, several matters were indeed troubling her, not the least the problems of her sister. She asked him to use his influence with the Pope to have the excommunication on Raoul and Petronilla lifted and their marriage recognised by the Church. In return, she would persuade Louis to make peace with Theobald of Champagne and recognise Pierre de la Chatre as Archbishop of Bourges. Bernard was appalled at her brazen candour. In his opinion, these affairs were no business of a twenty-two-year-old woman. He was, in fact, terrified of women and their possible effects on him. An adolescent, first experiencing physical desire for a young girl, he had been so filled with self-disgust that he had jumped into a freezing cold pond & remained there until his erection subsided. He strongly disapproved of his sister, who had married a rich man; because she enjoyed her wealth, he thought of her as a whore, spawned by Satan to lure her husband from the paths of righteousness, and refused to have anything to do with her. Nor would he allow his monks any contact with their female relatives. Now there stood before him the young, worldly, and disturbingly beautiful Queen of France, intent upon meddling in matters that were not her concern. Bernard's worst suspicions were confirmed: here, beyond doubt, was the source of that "Counsel of the Devil" that had urged the King on to disaster and plunged him into sin and guilt. His immediate reaction was to admonish Eleanor severely.””

Alison Weir

About This Quote

Source Historical account: 13th‑century French court, likely from her book on Eleanor of Aquitaine

Bernard, a monk, reacts with fear and moral condemnation to Queen Eleanor’s political maneuvering, revealing his misogyny and personal turmoil

In simple terms: A monk judges a queen’s political actions as sinful, driven by his own disgust and fear of women

Key Takeaway

Recognize personal bias and its impact on judgment

Themes

power gender religion politics morality

Mood

conflicted critical historical

Type

analytical critical historical

When to use this quote

  • court negotiations
  • religious petitions
  • personal confession

Key Concepts

misogyny self‑disgust political manipulation

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do personal insecurities shape our judgments?
  • Can political motives be separated from moral judgments?
A Different Perspective

Bernard’s reaction may stem from personal trauma, not objective moral authority

3.9 out of 5 (5 ratings)

More by Alison Weir

Explore all 51 Alison Weir quotes

More Bernard-of-clairvaux quotes

Browse all 2 Bernard-of-clairvaux quotes