For all his claims to be just a propagandist, [Bernard…
![“For all his claims to be just a propagandist, [Bernard Shaw's] writing has an effect nearer to that of music than most of those who have claimed to be writing "dramas of feeling." His plays are a joy to watch, not because they purport to deal with social and political problems, but because they…” quote by W.H. Auden](https://sms4smile.com/q/i/1b5/w-h-auden-2-7412_bernard-shaw_for-all-his-claims-to-be-just-a-propagan_3033582.jpg)
““For all his claims to be just a propagandist, [Bernard Shaw's] writing has an effect nearer to that of music than most of those who have claimed to be writing "dramas of feeling." His plays are a joy to watch, not because they purport to deal with social and political problems, but because they are such wonderful displays of conspicuous waste; the conversational energy displayed by his characters is so far in excess of what their situation requires that, if it were to be devoted to practical action, it would wreck the world in five minutes. The Mozart of English letters he is not – the music of the Marble Statue is beyond him – the Rossini, yes. He has all the brio, humor, cruel clarity and virtuosity of that master of opera buffa .””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
Auden praises Shaw’s theatrical flair, comparing it to music, while noting its excess and lack of practical impact.
In simple terms: Shaw’s plays are musical, energetic, but impractical.
Key Takeaway
Appreciate artistic brilliance, recognize limits.
Themes
theatre
artistic excess
music metaphor
practicality
Mood
analytical
appreciative
Type
critical
literary
When to use this quote
- theatre production
- literary analysis
- creative writing
- public discourse
Key Concepts
dramatic theory
cultural criticism
performance art
Questions to Reflect On
- What value does artistic extravagance hold?
- How can art balance beauty and purpose?
A Different Perspective
May dismiss Shaw’s social intent.