But, you may ask, if the two departments [i.e., federal…
![“But, you may ask, if the two departments [i.e., federal and state] should claim each the same subject of power, where is the common umpire to decide ultimately between them? In cases of little importance or urgency, the prudence of both parties will keep them aloof from the questionable ground…” quote by Thomas Jefferson](https://sms4smile.com/q/img-quotes/d33/thomas-jefferson-43_aloof_but-you-may-ask-if-the-two-departments-i_1638614.jpg)
“But, you may ask, if the two departments [i.e., federal and state] should claim each the same subject of power, where is the common umpire to decide ultimately between them? In cases of little importance or urgency, the prudence of both parties will keep them aloof from the questionable ground; but if it can neither be avoided nor compromised, a convention of the States must be called to ascribe the doubtful power to that department which they may think best.”
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
The passage debates jurisdictional conflict between federal and state powers, proposing a national convention to resolve disputes when neither can compromise.
In simple terms: States and federal government may clash over authority; a national body can decide.
Key Takeaway
Use a federal convention to settle power disputes.
Themes
government
federalism
jurisdiction
conflict resolution
Mood
analytical
concerned
Type
historical
legal
policy
When to use this quote
- legislative deadlock
- emergency decision making
- policy implementation
Key Concepts
constitutional law
political theory
intergovernmental relations
Questions to Reflect On
- What mechanisms exist today to resolve such disputes?
- Is a national convention practical in modern governance?
A Different Perspective
Political realities may prevent convening a convention quickly.