This is not (as you have charged) to paint religion with a…
““This is not (as you have charged) to paint religion with a broad brush. I am very quick to distinguish gradations of bad ideas; some clearly have no consequences at all (or at least not yet); some put civilization itself in peril. The problem with dogmatism, however, is that one can never quite predict how terrible its costs will be. To use one of my favorite examples, consider the Christian dogma that human life begins at the moment of conception: On its face, this belief seems likely to only improve our world. After all, it is the very quintessence of a life-affirming doctrine. Enter embryonic stem-cell research. Suddenly, this “life begins at the moment of conception” business becomes the chief impediment to medical progress. Who would have thought that such an innocuous idea could unnecessarily prolong the agony of tens of millions of people? This is the problem with dogmatism, no matter how seemingly benign: it is unresponsive to reality. Dogmatism is a failure of cognition (as well as a commitment to such failure); it is the state of being closed to new evidence and new arguments. And this frame of mind is rightly despised in every area of culture, on every subject, except where it goes by the name of “religious faith.” In this guise, parading its most grotesque faults as virtues, it is granted a special dispensation, even in the pages of Nature .””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
Dogmatism, especially religious, blocks progress by refusing to adjust beliefs despite evidence, leading to harmful consequences like hindering medical research.
In simple terms: Dogmatic beliefs ignore evidence and cause harm.
Question and adjust beliefs with evidence.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- public health policy
- bioethics debates
- education curricula
- legislative decisions
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- What evidence could shift a dogmatic view?
- How to balance respect for faith with scientific progress?
Changing deep‑seated beliefs is socially and emotionally challenging.