Skip to content

I compared what was really known about the stars with the…

“I compared what was really known about the stars with the account of creation as told in Genesis. I found that the writer of the inspired book had no knowledge of astronomy -- that he was as ignorant as a Choctaw chief -- as an Eskimo driver of dogs. Does any one imagine that the author of Genesis…” quote by Robert G. Ingersoll
Download Open image
““I compared what was really known about the stars with the account of creation as told in Genesis. I found that the writer of the inspired book had no knowledge of astronomy -- that he was as ignorant as a Choctaw chief -- as an Eskimo driver of dogs. Does any one imagine that the author of Genesis knew anything about the sun -- its size? that he was acquainted with Sirius, the North Star, with Capella, or that he knew anything of the clusters of stars so far away that their light, now visiting our eyes, has been traveling for two million years? If he had known these facts would he have said that Jehovah worked nearly six days to make this world, and only a part of the afternoon of the fourth day to make the sun and moon and all the stars? Yet millions of people insist that the writer of Genesis was inspired by the Creator of all worlds. Now, intelligent men, who are not frightened, whose brains have not been paralyzed by fear, know that the sacred story of creation was written by an ignorant savage. The story is inconsistent with all known facts, and every star shining in the heavens testifies that its author was an uninspired barbarian. I admit that this unknown writer was sincere, that he wrote what he believed to be true -- that he did the best he could. He did not claim to be inspired -- did not pretend that the story had been told to him by Jehovah. He simply stated the "facts" as he understood them. After I had learned a little about the stars I concluded that this writer, this "inspired" scribe, had been misled by myth and legend, and that he knew no more about creation than the average theologian of my day. In other words, that he knew absolutely nothing. And here, allow me to say that the ministers who are answering me are turning their guns in the wrong direction. These reverend gentlemen should attack the astronomers. They should malign and vilify Kepler, Copernicus, Newton, Herschel and Laplace. These men were the real destroyers of the sacred story. Then, after having disposed of them, they can wage a war against the stars, and against Jehovah himself for having furnished evidence against the truthfulness of his book.””

Robert G. Ingersoll

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The speaker argues that the Genesis creation story reflects the limited astronomical knowledge of its ancient author, making it scientifically inaccurate and thus not divinely inspired.

In simple terms: Genesis reflects ancient ignorance of astronomy.

Key Takeaway

Question ancient texts with modern science.

Themes

science religion myth history knowledge skepticism

Mood

critical skeptical inquisitive

Type

philosophical controversial

When to use this quote

  • education
  • public debate
  • faith discussions
  • science curricula
  • interfaith dialogue

Key Concepts

astronomy mythology inspiration authority

Questions to Reflect On

  • How should societies treat ancient religious narratives in light of modern science?
  • Can myth convey truth without factual accuracy?
A Different Perspective

The quote may overlook the symbolic or theological value of myth beyond literal facts.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Robert G. Ingersoll

Explore all 109 Robert G. Ingersoll quotes

More Astronomy quotes

Browse all 6,190 Astronomy quotes