Skip to content

I noted above that when I refer to an idea as unworthy of…

“I noted above that when I refer to an idea as unworthy of consideration (or words to that effect that might sound a bit harsher in context) I do not intend to cast aspersions on the intelligence or character of the one holding the unworthy belief. I must qualify that disclaimer. When I see or hear…” quote by Robert Carroll
Download Open image
““I noted above that when I refer to an idea as unworthy of consideration (or words to that effect that might sound a bit harsher in context) I do not intend to cast aspersions on the intelligence or character of the one holding the unworthy belief. I must qualify that disclaimer. When I see or hear of anyone murdering strangers because they believe such acts please their god, I consider not only the idea but the one holding such an idea to be unworthy of any sympathetic consideration. How anyone could come up with the idea that an almighty being would be pleased by causing as much misery as possible escapes my imagination. Such a person also escapes my capacity for mercy.””

Robert Carroll

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The author condemns extremist beliefs that justify violence, deeming both the idea and its holder unworthy of sympathy or mercy.

In simple terms: Extremist ideas that justify killing are intolerable and unworthy of compassion.

Key Takeaway

Reject extremist justifications for violence.

Themes

morality extremism compassion justice

Mood

ouful critical serious

Type

ethical philosophical

When to use this quote

  • debates on religious extremism
  • policy making on hate crimes
  • education on tolerance
  • media coverage of terrorism

Key Concepts

ethical judgment dehumanization religious violence

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do we address the roots of extremist ideology?
  • Can compassion ever be extended to those who commit atrocities?
A Different Perspective

Extremist beliefs may be rooted in complex social or psychological factors that require nuanced understanding.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Robert Carroll

Explore all 16 Robert Carroll quotes

More Character quotes

Browse all 32,707 Character quotes