Skip to content

Half a century ago Ostwald (1910) distinguished…

“Half a century ago Ostwald (1910) distinguished classicists and romanticists among the scientific investigators: the former being inclined to design schemes and to use consistently the deductions from working hypotheses; the latter being more fit for intuitive discoveries of functional relations…” quote by R.W. van Bemmelen
Download Open image
““Half a century ago Ostwald (1910) distinguished classicists and romanticists among the scientific investigators: the former being inclined to design schemes and to use consistently the deductions from working hypotheses; the latter being more fit for intuitive discoveries of functional relations between phenomena and therefore more able to open up new fields of study. Examples of both character types are Werner and Hutton. Werner was a real classicist. At the end of the eighteenth century he postulated the theory of “neptunism,” according to which all rocks including granites, were deposited in primeval seas. It was an artificial scheme, but, as a classification system, it worked quite satisfactorily at the time. Hutton, his contemporary and opponent, was more a romanticist. His concept of 'plutonism' supposed continually recurrent circuits of matter, which like gigantic paddle wheels raise material from various depths of the earth and carry it off again. This is a very flexible system which opens the mind to accept the possible occurrence in the course of time of a great variety of interrelated plutonic and tectonic processes.””

R.W. van Bemmelen

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Classicists favor systematic, deductive methods, while romanticists rely on intuition and flexible, discovery‑driven approaches.

In simple terms: Classicists use structured deduction; romanticists use intuition and flexibility.

Key Takeaway

Balance systematic analysis with intuitive insight.

Themes

science philosophy methodology history of science

Mood

curious analytical

Type

explanatory historical

When to use this quote

  • research design
  • academic teaching
  • innovation strategy

Key Concepts

deductive reasoning intuitive discovery theory development

Questions to Reflect On

  • When should you apply structured methods?
  • How can intuition be validated scientifically?
A Different Perspective

Rigid classicism may stifle creativity.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by R.W. van Bemmelen

Explore all 2 R.W. van Bemmelen quotes

More Classicists quotes

Browse all 15 Classicists quotes