Skip to content

Of course the no-government ethics will meet with at least…

“Of course the no-government ethics will meet with at least as many objections as the no-capital economics. Our minds have been so nurtured in prejudices as to the providential functions of government that anarchist ideas must be received with distrust. Our whole education, from childhood to the…” quote by Pyotr Kropotkin
Download Open image
““Of course the no-government ethics will meet with at least as many objections as the no-capital economics. Our minds have been so nurtured in prejudices as to the providential functions of government that anarchist ideas must be received with distrust. Our whole education, from childhood to the grave, nurtures the belief in the necessity of a government and its beneficial effects. Systems of philosophy have been elaborated to support this view; history has been written from this standpoint; theories of law have been circulated and taught for the same purpose. All politics are based on the same principle, each politician saying to people he wants to support him: “Give me the governmental power; I will, I can, relieve you from the hardships of your present life.” All our education is permeated with the same teachings. We may open any book of sociology, history, law, or ethics: everywhere we find government, its organisation, its deeds, playing so prominent a part that we grow accustomed to suppose that the State and the political men are everything; that there is nothing behind the big statesmen. The same teachings are daily repeated in the Press. Whole columns are filled up with minutest records of parliamentary debates, of movements of political persons. And, while reading these columns, we too often forget that besides those few men whose importance has been so swollen up as to overshadow humanity, there is an immense body of men—mankind, in fact—growing and dying, living in happiness or sorrow, labouring and consuming, thinking and creating. And yet, if we revert from the printed matter to our real life, and cast a broad glance on society as it is, we are struck with the infinitesimal part played by government in our life. Millions of human beings live and die without having had anything to do with government. Every day millions of transactions are made without the slightest interference of government; and those who enter into agreements have not the slightest intention of breaking bargains. Nay, those agreements which are not protected by government (those of the exchange, or card debts) am perhaps better kept than any others. The simple habit of keeping one's word, the desire of not losing confidence, are quite sufficient in an overwhelming majority of cases to enforce the keeping of agreements. Of course it may be said that there is still the government which might enforce them if necessary. But without speaking of the numberless cases which could not even be brought before a court, everyone who has the slightest acquaintance with trade will undoubtedly confirm the assertion that, if there were not so strong a feeling of honour in keeping agreements, trade itself would become utterly impossible.””

Pyotr Kropotkin

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The passage argues that societies are conditioned to view government as essential, yet most daily human activity occurs independently of state intervention.

In simple terms: We are taught to see government as central, but most life happens without it.

Key Takeaway

Question the assumed necessity of government in everyday life.

Themes

politics government education media anarchism

Mood

critical reflective inquisitive

Type

philosophical political analytical

When to use this quote

  • daily transactions
  • community organization
  • personal decision-making
  • media consumption
  • educational curricula

Key Concepts

social contract state power ideology individual autonomy

Questions to Reflect On

  • What would society look like without government oversight?
  • How do we balance individual freedom with collective security?
A Different Perspective

The view may overlook the benefits and protections governments provide in certain contexts.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Pyotr Kropotkin

Explore all 41 Pyotr Kropotkin quotes

More Anarchism quotes

Browse all 388 Anarchism quotes