Skip to content

Incidentally, I do not agree with you when you speak of…

“Incidentally, I do not agree with you when you speak of Indian independence having become a foregone conclusion. Independence is not something you can divide into phases. It exists or does not exist. Certain steps might be taken to help bring it into existence, others can be taken that will hinder…” quote by Paul Scott
Download Open image
““Incidentally, I do not agree with you when you speak of Indian independence having become a foregone conclusion. Independence is not something you can divide into phases. It exists or does not exist. Certain steps might be taken to help bring it into existence, others can be taken that will hinder it doing so. But independence alone is not the idea I pursue, nor the idea which the party I belong to tries to pursue, no doubt making many errors and misjudgements in the process. The idea, you know, isn’t simply to get rid of the British. It is to create a nation capable of getting rid of them and capable simultaneously of taking its place in the world as a nation, and we know that every internal division of our interests hinders the creation of such a nation. That is why we go on insisting that the Congress is an All India Congress. It is an All India Congress first, because you cannot detach from it the idea that it is right that it should be. Only second is it a political party, although one day that is what it must become. Meanwhile, Governor-ji, we try to do the job that your Government has always found it beneficial to leave undone, the job of unifying India, of making all Indians feel that they are, above all else, Indians. You think perhaps we do this to put up a strong front against the British. Partly only you would be right. Principally we do it for the sake of India when you are gone. And we are working mostly in the dark with only a small glimmer of light ahead, because we have never had that kind of India, we do not know what kind of India that will be. This is why I say we are looking for a country. I can look for it better in prison, I’m afraid, than from a seat on your Excellency’s executive council.””

Paul Scott

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Independence is a binary state; it cannot be phased. True nationhood requires unity and the ability to replace colonial rule, not merely its removal.

In simple terms: Independence is all-or-nothing; unity is essential.

Key Takeaway

Focus on building a unified national identity.

Themes

nationhood unity colonialism political strategy

Mood

determined hopeful determined

Type

political philosophical inspirational

When to use this quote

  • political negotiations
  • grassroots mobilization
  • constitutional drafting
  • post‑colonial nation building

Key Concepts

statehood self-determination national identity

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can diverse groups forge a shared identity?
  • What steps ensure unity without suppressing regional voices?
A Different Perspective

Independence alone does not guarantee a functional nation; internal divisions can undermine it.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Paul Scott

Explore all 80 Paul Scott quotes

More Freedom quotes

Browse all 30,110 Freedom quotes