This is, indeed, an insightful observation. The Archbishop…
““This is, indeed, an insightful observation. The Archbishop [Joseph L. Berardin] insists that the natural resemblance between Christ and his priests must not stop merely with the fact that they share a common masculinity. Our question is, 'Why must it BEGIN there?' If the faithful cannot see Christ in a male who exemplifies no godlike virtues - humility, gentleness, and self-effacing service - can they not see him in a female who does? Indeed, if the priest acts 'in persona Christi,' not 'in masculinitate Christi,' then 'NATURAL resemblance' between Christ and the priest, it would seem, does not entail PHYSICAL, that is SEXUAL resemblance, but a resemblance which is natural to the SPIRITUAL order with which the worshiping congregation has to do. And in this order there is neither male nor female, even as there is neither Jew nor Greek. We would, therefore, conclude that since the Word was made flesh, as the apostle John has declared him (John 1:14), we rightly heed those who, in the flesh, symbolize his presence as they speak and act in his name. But we see no reason to add to what the apostle said by insisting that the Word was made MALE flesh, for both male and female are equally bearers of the divine image. And since God created humankind in his image, male AND female, we can only conclude that women as well as men should be ordained to the priesthood, because femaleness, like maleness, is a fitting symbol (sacramental sign) of Deity.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
The argument asserts that spiritual likeness, not physical gender, qualifies priests, supporting women’s ordination as equally embodying the divine image.
In simple terms: Spiritual likeness, not gender, qualifies priesthood.
Advocate gender‑inclusive ordination.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- church leadership discussions
- seminary curricula
- advocacy meetings
- interfaith dialogues
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How does spiritual symbolism affect gender roles?
- What steps can promote inclusive ordination?
Traditional views resist change.