Skip to content

Now "The Arabian Nights," some of which, but not nearly…

“Now "The Arabian Nights," some of which, but not nearly all, are given in this volume, are only fairy tales of the East. The people of Asia, Arabia, and Persia told them in their own way, not for children, but for grown-up people. There were no novels then, nor any printed books, of course; but…” quote by Muhsin Mahdi
Download Open image
““Now "The Arabian Nights," some of which, but not nearly all, are given in this volume, are only fairy tales of the East. The people of Asia, Arabia, and Persia told them in their own way, not for children, but for grown-up people. There were no novels then, nor any printed books, of course; but there were people whose profession it was to amuse men and women by telling tales. They dressed the fairy stories up, and made the characters good Mahommedans, living in Bagdad or India. The events were often supposed to happen in the reign of the great Caliph, or ruler of the Faithful, Haroun al Raschid, who lived in Bagdad in 786-808 A.D. The vizir who accompanies the Caliph was also a real person of the great family of the Barmecides. He was put to death by the Caliph in a very cruel way, nobody ever knew why. The stories must have been told in their present shape a good long while after the Caliph died, when nobody knew very exactly what had really happened. At last some storyteller thought of writing down the tales, and fixing them into a kind of framework, as if they had all been narrated to a cruel Sultan by his wife. Probably the tales were written down about the time when Edward I. was fighting Robert Bruce. But changes were made in them at different times, and a great deal that is very dull and stupid was put in, and plenty of verses. Neither the verses nor the dull pieces are given in this book.””

Muhsin Mahdi

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The tales are adult‑oriented folk stories, adapted over centuries, with added verses and alterations, reflecting cultural transmission and authorial changes.

In simple terms: Arabian Nights evolved via oral and written adaptations.

Key Takeaway

Appreciate the layered history of stories.

Themes

literature folklore cultural transmission adaptation history

Mood

educational historical reflective

Type

Different times:1 Fairy tale:1 Fairy tales:1 Men and women:0 Real person:0 Storytelling:1 Telling Tales:1 Tales Written:1 Caliph Cruel:0 Persia Told:0

When to use this quote

  • academic study
  • storytelling workshops
  • translation projects
  • media adaptation

Key Concepts

Oral tradition textual criticism cultural hybridity

Questions to Reflect On

  • What influences change folk narratives?
  • How do added verses affect story meaning?
A Different Perspective

Modern retellings may distort original contexts.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Muhsin Mahdi

Explore all 2 Muhsin Mahdi quotes

More Different times quotes

Browse all 376 Different times quotes