Skip to content

...any object functioning within the physical laws of any…

“...any object functioning within the physical laws of any particular universe does not have free will ... In terms of human beings, all behavior and cognition cannot appear out of thin air. Behavior and cognition must be the result of prior causes. This is because our brains obey the same laws of…” quote by Mark J. Solomon
Download Open image
““...any object functioning within the physical laws of any particular universe does not have free will ... In terms of human beings, all behavior and cognition cannot appear out of thin air. Behavior and cognition must be the result of prior causes. This is because our brains obey the same laws of a cause and effect physical universe just like any other physical object. All events that occur in the universe are caused by antecedent events. Quantum indeterminacy, which maintains that the state of a system does not determine a unique collection of values for all its measurable properties, is not a valid argument for free will and has been used incorrectly to justify beliefs of independent decision-making. Logically speaking, notions of randomness and indeterminism are actually additional arguments against free will. All events that occur at random in the universe are, by definition, not caused by antecedent events. Or to say it a different way, any random event cannot also be a willed event. By the process of elimination, events that are “willed freely” are events that are neither determined nor random. In other words, in all likelihood events that are “willed freely” are events that simply do not exist.””

Mark J. Solomon

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

All events are determined by prior causes; randomness does not support free will, so truly free actions likely do not exist.

In simple terms: Determinism negates free will.

Key Takeaway

Accept causality, focus on understanding causes.

Themes

philosophy science determinism free will causality

Mood

analytical thoughtful

Type

philosophical scientific

When to use this quote

  • academic debates
  • philosophical discussions
  • science education

Key Concepts

physics psychology metaphysics quantum theory

Questions to Reflect On

  • Can randomness ever influence decisions?
  • How do we reconcile feeling of choice with determinism?
A Different Perspective

Complex quantum concepts may be oversimplified.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Mark J. Solomon

Explore all 2 Mark J. Solomon quotes

More Cause and effect quotes

Browse all 519 Cause and effect quotes