Skip to content

In a word, commercial competition, under the paternal…

“In a word, commercial competition, under the paternal aegis of the law, allows the great majority of merchants-— and this fact is attested to in countless medical inquests-— adulterate provisions and drink, sell pernicious substances as wholesome food, and kill by slow poisoning… Let people say…” quote by Élisée Reclus
Download Open image
““In a word, commercial competition, under the paternal aegis of the law, allows the great majority of merchants-— and this fact is attested to in countless medical inquests-— adulterate provisions and drink, sell pernicious substances as wholesome food, and kill by slow poisoning… Let people say what they will, slavery, which abolitionists strove so gallantly to extirpate in America, prevails in another form in every civilized country; for entire populations, placed between the alternatives of death by starvation and toils which they detest, are constrained to choose the latter. And if we would deal frankly with the barbarous society to which we belong, we must acknowledge that murder, albeit disguised under a thousand insidious and scientific forms, still, as in the times of primitive savagery, terminates the majority of lives.””

Élisée Reclus

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Commercial competition under law permits merchants to sell harmful goods, leading to widespread slow poisoning and a new form of slavery where people choose toil over starvation.

In simple terms: Law‑regulated markets can hide harmful practices, forcing people into harmful labor.

Key Takeaway

Recognize and challenge hidden harms in regulated markets.

Themes

economics ethics public health slavery consumer protection

Mood

critical concerned

Type

analytical political

When to use this quote

  • food industry
  • consumer advocacy
  • policy reform
  • public health campaigns

Key Concepts

market regulation systemic exploitation public policy food safety

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can we strengthen regulations to prevent harmful products?
  • What responsibilities do consumers have in exposing such practices?
A Different Perspective

Legal frameworks often fail to protect vulnerable populations from corporate malfeasance.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Élisée Reclus

Explore all 7 Élisée Reclus quotes

More Abolitionists quotes

Browse all 27 Abolitionists quotes