Skip to content

There existed very long saxophones from years ago. The…

“There existed very long saxophones from years ago. The player sat on their chair like a cellist; that same sort of feeling to it as well - unlike for example the way a harpist would be: the whole act differing in a very fundamental sense. Although harpists are fine. There is nothing to be said…” quote by James Kelman
Download Open image
““There existed very long saxophones from years ago. The player sat on their chair like a cellist; that same sort of feeling to it as well - unlike for example the way a harpist would be: the whole act differing in a very fundamental sense. Although harpists are fine. There is nothing to be said against harpists by any means whatsoever.””

James Kelman

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The quote contrasts the physical posture and emotional feel of playing saxophone with that of a harpist, highlighting differences in performance style and perception.

In simple terms: Saxophone playing feels different from harp playing.

Key Takeaway

Recognize unique qualities of each art form.

Themes

music performance comparison perception

Mood

reflective analytical neutral

Type

observational comparative

When to use this quote

  • jazz performance
  • classical recital
  • music education
  • instrument selection

Key Concepts

instrument technique embodiment artistic expression

Questions to Reflect On

  • How does posture affect musical expression?
  • What can we learn from comparing disparate instruments?
A Different Perspective

Different instruments demand distinct physical and emotional approaches, limiting direct comparison.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by James Kelman

Explore all 14 James Kelman quotes

More Harp quotes

Browse all 95 Harp quotes