Skip to content

…let us point out precisely the difficulties of empiricism…

“…let us point out precisely the difficulties of empiricism as a theory of knowledge. First, it begins with two fixed, unchangeable ultimates--mind and matter. Second, it asserts that knowledge is the agreement of ideas with each other, in which case we are not dealing with nature or things at all…” quote by Holly Estil Cunningham
Download Open image
““…let us point out precisely the difficulties of empiricism as a theory of knowledge. First, it begins with two fixed, unchangeable ultimates--mind and matter. Second, it asserts that knowledge is the agreement of ideas with each other, in which case we are not dealing with nature or things at all, and consequently, have left out one of our ultimates. Third, it then asserts (for it is essential that knowledge should somehow or other be connected with things) that knowledge consists in the agreement between an idea and a thing; and in this case we can never tell when the agreement takes place; and furthermore, it is impossible for ideas and things to disagree, for, according to the theory, ideas are copies of things. This means that empiricism can not account for the fact of error . Every theory of knowledge must make a place for error, for, as is evident, error seems to be as industrious as truth. Consequently, if knowledge actually does take place, if there is such an activity, thing, or relation as knowledge, empiricism fails to give an account of it which is free from contradictions. The moral is, as the stories in our school readers say, don't begin with fixed things, for they beguileth one into inconsistencies.””

Holly Estil Cunningham

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Empiricism’s fixed premises of mind and matter, and its idea‑thing agreement, cannot explain error, leading to contradictions in knowledge theory.

In simple terms: Empiricism can’t explain error, so it’s contradictory.

Key Takeaway

Question assumptions about unchanging foundations.

Themes

philosophy epistemology logic

Mood

critical inquisitive

Type

theoretical analytical

When to use this quote

  • academic debate
  • teaching philosophy
  • critical essays

Key Concepts

empiricism error contradiction

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can we incorporate error into a theory of knowledge?
  • What alternatives address empiricism’s flaws?
A Different Perspective

Empiricism may still be useful in practical science despite its limits.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Holly Estil Cunningham

Explore all 7 Holly Estil Cunningham quotes

More Empiricism quotes

Browse all 98 Empiricism quotes