Skip to content

I heard a young city boy ask an elderly Papago woman if…

“I heard a young city boy ask an elderly Papago woman if, lacking a harvesting pole, one could ever collect fruit off the tall cacti by throwing rocks at the tops to knock the fruit down. 'NO!' Marquita replied with a strain of horror in her voice. 'The saguaros- they are Indians too. You don't…” quote by Gary Paul Nabhan
Download Open image
““I heard a young city boy ask an elderly Papago woman if, lacking a harvesting pole, one could ever collect fruit off the tall cacti by throwing rocks at the tops to knock the fruit down. 'NO!' Marquita replied with a strain of horror in her voice. 'The saguaros- they are Indians too. You don't EVER throw ANYTHING at them. If you hit them on the head with rocks you could kill them. You don't ever stick anything sharp into their skin either, or they will just dry up and die. You don't do anything to hurt them. They are Indians.””

Gary Paul Nabhan

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Respect for living beings extends to plants, recognizing their cultural and ecological significance; harming them is akin to harming people.

In simple terms: Treat plants with respect as sentient beings.

Key Takeaway

Avoid harming cacti; honor their life.

Themes

environmental ethics indigenous wisdom respect for life

Mood

reflective respectful

Type

ethical philosophical

When to use this quote

  • gardening
  • landscape design
  • environmental education
  • policy making
  • community outreach

Key Concepts

ecology cultural reverence biocentrism

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do we balance cultural respect with practical uses of plants?
  • What responsibilities do we have toward non-human life?
A Different Perspective

The advice may conflict with agricultural needs for resource extraction.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Gary Paul Nabhan

Explore all 8 Gary Paul Nabhan quotes

More Throwing rocks quotes

Browse all 20 Throwing rocks quotes