Planck...and Bohr...have invented systems containing…
![“Planck...and Bohr...have invented systems containing electrons of which the motion produces no effect upon external charges...[N]ot only [is this] inconsistent with the accepted laws of electromagnetism, but I may add, is logically objectionable, for that state of motion which produces no physical…” quote by G.N.Lewis](https://sms4smile.com/q/img-quotes/363/g-n-lewis-101729_chemistry_planck-and-bohr-have-invented-systems-co_993371.jpg)
““Planck...and Bohr...have invented systems containing electrons of which the motion produces no effect upon external charges...[N]ot only [is this] inconsistent with the accepted laws of electromagnetism, but I may add, is logically objectionable, for that state of motion which produces no physical effect whatsoever may better be called a state of rest.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
Lewis critiques that a state where electron motion has no external effect contradicts electromagnetism and is logically untenable
In simple terms: Electrons moving without affecting charges defy physics
Key Takeaway
Question and test physical consistency of motion
Themes
physics
philosophy
science
Mood
critical
inquisitive
Type
scientific
philosophical
When to use this quote
- academic discussion
- theoretical physics
- educational lectures
Key Concepts
electromagnetism
rest
theory critique
Questions to Reflect On
- How do we reconcile theoretical models with observable phenomena?
- What experiments could test this claim?
A Different Perspective
The claim assumes idealized conditions rarely met in practice