Skip to content

An old lady had an Alderney cow, which she looked upon as…

“An old lady had an Alderney cow, which she looked upon as a daughter. …The whole town knew and kindly regarded Miss Betsy Barker's Alderney, therefore great was the sympathy and regret when, in an unguarded moment, the poor cow fell into a lime-pit. She moaned so loudly that she was soon heard and…” quote by Elizabeth Gaskell
Download Open image
““An old lady had an Alderney cow, which she looked upon as a daughter. …The whole town knew and kindly regarded Miss Betsy Barker's Alderney, therefore great was the sympathy and regret when, in an unguarded moment, the poor cow fell into a lime-pit. She moaned so loudly that she was soon heard and rescued; but meanwhile the poor beast had lost most of her hair and came out looking naked, cold and miserable, in a bare skin. Everybody pitied the animal, though a few could not restrain their smiles at her droll appearance. Miss Betsy Barker absolutely cried with sorrow and dismay; and it was said she thought of trying a bath of oil. This remedy, perhaps, was recommended by some one of the number whose advice she asked; but the proposal, if ever it was made, was knocked on the head by Captain Brown's decided "Get her a flannel waistcoat and flannel drawers, ma'am, if you wish to keep her alive, But my advice is, kill the poor creature at once." Miss Betsy Barker dried her eyes, and thanked the Captain heartily; she set to work, and by-and-by all the town turned out to see the Alderney meekly going to her pasture, clad in dark grey flannel.I have watched her myself many a time. Do you ever see cows dressed in grey flannel in London?””

Elizabeth Gaskell

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

A woman treats her cow as a child, and the community's mixed sympathy highlights human empathy and absurdity when disaster strikes.

In simple terms: A lady loves her cow like a daughter; townsfolk feel pity and amusement when it gets hurt.

Key Takeaway

Recognize compassion but also the absurdity of over‑protecting.

Themes

empathy community absurdity loss humor

Mood

sympathetic reflective lighthearted

Type

anecdotal humorous social commentary

When to use this quote

  • rural life
  • animal care
  • public reaction
  • humor in tragedy

Key Concepts

anthropomorphism social norms grief irony

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do we balance empathy with practicality?
  • When does humor become disrespectful?
A Different Perspective

The humor may downplay the genuine grief of loss.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Elizabeth Gaskell

Explore all 330 Elizabeth Gaskell quotes

More Bare skin quotes

Browse all 88 Bare skin quotes