Such frankness, even over good tidings, was a further…
““Such frankness, even over good tidings, was a further offense to Mr. Fremlin. He felt that it was casual and indecent. Like most countrymen, he had a great respect for traditional mysteries. A little skill decently wrapped up impressed him far more than twice the amount flung nakedly at his feet. Old Dr. Milsom had satisfied his sense of propriety. Never, never would he have told a patient whether or not she was going to live or die; the temperature was his secret, even the name of the complain transpired only in dark hints. Standing by the bedside he would shake his head and purse his lips and consult his gold turnip-watch, so that you felt you were getting the benefit of a rare and esoteric wisdom.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
The passage critiques a doctor's overcautiousness and secretiveness, juxtaposing professional propriety with the harsh reality of life and death.
In simple terms: Doctor hides truth behind propriety.
Key Takeaway
Balance honesty with professionalism.
Themes
ethics
medicine
communication
Mood
critical
humorous
Type
Bedside:1
Esoteric wisdom:0
Frankness:1
Humor:0
Live or die:0
Respect:1
Told Patient:0
Bedside Shake:0
Frankness Good:0
When to use this quote
- in medical training
- patient interactions
- ethical discussions
Key Concepts
patient care
professional boundaries
truthfulness
humor
Questions to Reflect On
- When is secrecy justified?
- How to convey bad news compassionately?
A Different Perspective
Overly secretive behavior can erode trust.