Skip to content

Addressing this doubt, in order to explain the mind, it is…

“Addressing this doubt, in order to explain the mind, it is taught: || citir eva cetana-padād avarūḍhā cetya-saṅkocinī cittam || 5 || Awareness (citi) itself, descending from its state of pure consciousness (cetana), becomes contracted by the object perceived: this is [called] the mind (citta). Far…” quote by Christopher D. Wallis
Download Open image
““Addressing this doubt, in order to explain the mind, it is taught: || citir eva cetana-padād avarūḍhā cetya-saṅkocinī cittam || 5 || Awareness (citi) itself, descending from its state of pure consciousness (cetana), becomes contracted by the object perceived: this is [called] the mind (citta). Far from teaching an absolute distinction of divine spirit and mundane matter, Tantra teaches that they are in fact different phases of one thing, i.e., Awareness. Take the example of h2o: in one phase, we call it steam, in another, water, in another, ice. These three states are very different from one another, and we necessarily interact with each of them in very different ways. This is a perfect analogy for what Kṣemarāja intends here: there are three different states or phases of one ‘thing’—in one state, we call it God, in another, pure consciousness, in another, the mind. The implications of this are of course huge. First, though, let’s explore the specific three terms that Kṣemarāja is using here for these three states of the One. First we have citi, introduced in the first sūtra, which we translate (imperfectly) as Awareness. Citi (pronounced CHIT-ee) is the state in which Awareness is fully expanded, that is to say, untouched by any trace of contraction, including that of subjectivity or selfhood. In other words, there is no concealment whatsoever operative on the citi level (not that it’s really a level, of course). When citi manifests as an individuated subject, then that is the phase called cetana, here translated as ‘pure consciousness’. We have to define this second phase, cetana, more carefully so that we don’t confuse it with the third phase (the mind). Cetana (CHAY-tuh-nuh) is the state of being the conscious knower or agent of consciousness. We experience cetana in the space between trains of thought, a space of awareness momentarily devoid of thought-forms (vikalpas). That’s why I translate it as ‘pure consciousness’. We experience it dozens of times a day, but usually only for a second, and usually without the reflective self-awareness (vimarśa) by which we can know that we are experiencing cetana. (This ‘knowing’, when it does occur, does not take the form of a thought, or else it is no longer the cetana state.) The cetana state is open and expansive awareness; in fact, it is as expanded as awareness can be while still having a subtle ‘sense of self’.””

Christopher D. Wallis

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Awareness expands from pure consciousness to mind, showing phases of a single reality like water states.

In simple terms: Awareness changes form like water.

Key Takeaway

Observe how consciousness shifts across states.

Themes

philosophy mindfulness spirituality

Mood

reflective inquisitive

Type

Philosophy of Mind:1 Pure Consciousness:1 Consciousness Mind:1 Consciousness Cetana:1 Mind Citta:1 Cetana Knowing:1

When to use this quote

  • meditation
  • psychotherapy
  • spiritual study

Key Concepts

consciousness identity dualism

Questions to Reflect On

  • What state of awareness are you experiencing?
  • How can this analogy aid self‑knowledge?
A Different Perspective

Complex terminology may confuse beginners.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Christopher D. Wallis

Explore all 2 Christopher D. Wallis quotes

More Different ways quotes

Browse all 2,175 Different ways quotes