In the process of building an inspiring and attractive…
““In the process of building an inspiring and attractive alternative government, Liberals will not follow in Lord Derby's oft-quoted advice, given in 1841, that 'the duty of an Opposition is to oppose everything, and propose nothing'. The British Tories did not win a parliamentary majority for the next thirty-three years, and if the Liberals adopted such a strategy, we too could be in the political wilderness for a long time. As Menzies once put it: 'The duty of an Opposition, if it has no ambition to be permanently on the left-hand side of the Speaker, is not to Oppose for Opposition's sake, but to oppose selectively. No Government is always wrong on everything, whatever the critics may say. The Opposition must choose the grounds on which to attack. To attack indiscriminately is to risk public opinion, which has a reserve of fairness not always understood'. Indeed, simply opposing the government may create headlines, but to win an election you need to present an alternative.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
Opposition should offer constructive alternatives rather than merely opposing; selective critique builds credibility.
In simple terms: Oppose wisely, propose alternatives.
Focus on constructive criticism.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- campaign planning
- debate preparation
- policy drafting
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can you balance critique with solutions?
- What makes an alternative compelling?
Pure opposition can alienate voters.