Carbon dioxide Quote by Yuval Noah Harari
““Finally, some scientists concede that consciousness is real and may actually have great moral and political value, but that it fulfils no biological function whatsoever. Consciousness is the biologically useless by-product of certain brain processes. Jet engines roar loudly, but the noise doesn’t propel the aeroplane forward. Humans don’t need carbon dioxide, but each and every breath fills the air with more of the stuff. Similarly, consciousness may be a kind of mental pollution produced by the firing of complex neural networks. It doesn’t do anything. It is just there. If this is true, it implies that all the pain and pleasure experienced by billions of creatures for millions of years is just mental pollution. This is certainly a thought worth thinking, even if it isn’t true. But it is quite amazing to realise that as of 2016, this is the best theory of consciousness that contemporary science has to offer us. Maybe””
About This Quote
Source Book: Homo Deus, 2015
Consciousness may be a useless by‑product of brain activity, like noise from a jet engine, without biological purpose.
In simple terms: Consciousness could be mental waste with no function.
Question the purpose of experience.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- debates on AI rights
- animal welfare
- neuroscience research
- existential reflection
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- Is moral consideration justified without function?
- How does this view affect our treatment of sentient beings?
If consciousness has no function, moral value may be illusory.