Skip to content

Executions Quote by William Goldman

“I don't know that you'll understand this, but once upon a time, long ago, I was a scholar and a marathon man, but that fella's gone now, dead I suppose, but I remember something he thought, which was that if you don't learn the mistakes of the past, you'll be doomed to repeat them. Well we've been…” quote by William Goldman
Download Open image
““I don't know that you'll understand this, but once upon a time, long ago, I was a scholar and a marathon man, but that fella's gone now, dead I suppose, but I remember something he thought, which was that if you don't learn the mistakes of the past, you'll be doomed to repeat them. Well we've been making a mistake with people like you, because public trials are bullshit and executions are games for winners - all this time we should have been giving back pain. That's the real lesson. That's the loser's share, just pain, pure and simple, pain and torture, no hotshot lawyers running around trying to see that justice is done. I think we'd have a nice peaceful place here if all you warmakers knew you better not start something because if you lost, agony was just around the bend. That's what I'd like to give you. Agony. Not what you're suffering now. I mean a lifetime of it, 'cause that's the only degree of justice I think we're ready for down here yet, and I know any humanist might disagree with me too, but I don't think you will, because you had a lot to do with educating me, I'm like you now, except I'm better at it, because you're going to die and I've still got a long way to go.””

William Goldman

About This Quote

Source Film: The Princess Bride, 1987

The speaker argues that true justice is harsh, advocating suffering as the appropriate recompense for wrongdoing, rejecting lenient legal processes.

In simple terms: Justice should be painful, not forgiving.

Key Takeaway

Embrace harsh consequences for justice.

Themes

justice retribution punishment morality power

Mood

dark grim serious

Type

philosophical critical cautionary

When to use this quote

  • courtroom decisions
  • political oppression
  • personal vendettas
  • authoritarian regimes

Key Concepts

retributive justice philosophy of punishment ethical absolutism

Questions to Reflect On

  • Is suffering an effective deterrent?
  • Can justice be both fair and compassionate?
A Different Perspective

Painful justice may perpetuate cycles of violence and ignore rehabilitation.

2.4 out of 5 (9 ratings)

More by William Goldman

Explore all 281 William Goldman quotes

More Executions quotes

Browse all 32 Executions quotes