Scholasticism Quote by William D. Dennison
““As most Van Tilians realize, Van Til fought diligently to purge the Reformed tradition from the remnants of scholasticism that remained in the thought of Old Princeton, Kuyper, and Bavinck. In light of that purging, presently it seems that those Van Tilians influenced by Frame are unsatisfied with Van Til’s view that the sole Archimedean point of a Christian epistemology is the ontological and economic Trinity. Henceforth, these Van Tilians are beginning to supplement the ground of epistemology with something within the creation. As I see it, Frame has been the catalyst for this movement; he is the transitional figure. In this context, I predict that there will be a renewed appreciation for Aquinas and scholasticism, even among Van Tilians.””
About This Quote
Source Book: The Van Til Tradition, William D. Dennison, 2005
Van Til sought to remove scholastic remnants from Reformed theology, but newer Van Tilians, influenced by Frame, are re‑introducing creation‑based epistemology, prompting a revival of Aquinas and scholastic thought.
In simple terms: Van Til removed scholasticism; newer scholars re‑add creation‑based ideas, reviving Aquinas.
Key Takeaway
Recognize the value of both tradition and new insight.
Themes
theology
philosophy
history of ideas
epistemology
Mood
reflective
analytical
hopeful
Type
theoretical
historical
critical
When to use this quote
- seminar discussions
- academic research
- church teaching
- personal study
Key Concepts
Reformed tradition
scholasticism
creation
Trinitarian epistemology
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we balance historic doctrine with contemporary insights?
- What benefits arise from revisiting Aquinas?
A Different Perspective
Some may argue that re‑introducing scholasticism risks diluting Reformed distinctives.
