Every man Quote by Thomas Merton
““In a state where “liberty” is based on the “rights” of each individual there can never be true justice. But in a state where you get to discussing the rights of beavers, then there is the danger not only of injustice but of violence and general ruin, through a kind of contagious madness that could sweep the country as the fear of the Martians swept New Jersey. (Rights: if a state guarantees the Rights of all men: men either will or will not demand the extreme limit of what they are entitled to. Furthermore, it is even their right to keep more than they have a right to if they can get it legally (or even illegally, as long as the injured party doesn’t complain and demand his rights). Now everybody does not demand the full extent of his rights. Most people, to tell the truth, don’t care. But some get as much as they can get; more than they have a “right” to; they take over the “rights” of many many others who don’t really care. Thus they become so big that they are monuments, and everyone looks up to them, and makes it his ideal to get that much more of his rights too (if he only could!). The ideal is greed and avarice. How can there be justice or liberty in such a state? Yet imagine the pandemonium if every man set out to demand at once the full extent of his (nebulous) rights, and the whole nation were swept by completely active and murderous avarice!)””
About This Quote
Source Essay: “The Danger of Rights” by Thomas Merton, 1960
When individual rights are treated as absolute claims, society can become consumed by greed and conflict, undermining true justice and liberty.
In simple terms: Unlimited rights lead to chaos and inequality.
Balance rights with responsibility.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- political debate
- legal reform
- community activism
- education on civic duty
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can societies limit rights without oppression?
- What mechanisms protect against collective avarice?
If everyone pursues maximal rights, the system collapses under greed.