Agnostic Quote by Robert M. Price
“I do not expect that the mere fact that I was once an evangelical apologist and now see things differently should itself count as evidence that I must be right. That would be the genetic fallacy. It would be just as erroneous to think that John Rankin must be right in having embraced evangelical Christianity since he had once been an agnostic Unitarian and repudiated it for the Christian faith.”
About This Quote
Source Book: The New Testament: A Critique of the Christian Faith, 2005
The speaker warns against judging truth based on a person’s past beliefs, highlighting the genetic fallacy.
In simple terms: Don’t judge ideas by who they came from.
Key Takeaway
Focus on evidence, not origins.
Themes
critical thinking
logic
bias
religion
argumentation
Mood
skeptical
analytical
reflective
Type
philosophical
critical
academic
When to use this quote
- debates on faith
- academic discussions
- personal belief changes
- public policy arguments
- media commentary
Key Concepts
genetic fallacy
epistemology
argument analysis
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you evaluate arguments independent of their source?
- When is a person’s history relevant to their claim?
A Different Perspective
It may overlook genuine transformation or new insights that arise from personal experience.
![“...[T]oday's Washington is about as attentive to the Tenth Amendment as the Unitarian Church is to the Book of Revelation.” quote by Joseph Sobran](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/b72/joseph-sobran-6902_amendments_t-oday-s-washington-is-about-as-attentiv_404524.jpg)
