Any Quote by Robert Byrd
“And the president is all wrong when he maintains that a nominee should have an up-or-down vote. The Constitution doesn't say that. The Constitution doesn't say that that nominee shall have any vote at all. There doesn't have to even be a vote.”
About This Quote
Constitutional text does not specify voting rights for nominees, suggesting flexibility in interpretation.
In simple terms: The Constitution is silent on nominee voting.
Key Takeaway
Question assumptions about constitutional requirements.
Themes
law
constitution
politics
Mood
critical
analytical
Type
political
legal
When to use this quote
- senate voting
- judicial appointments
- constitutional debate
Key Concepts
interpretation
legislative process
Questions to Reflect On
- Should we rely on tradition or strict text?
- How can we ensure fair nominee selection?
A Different Perspective
Ignoring the silence may lead to overreach.
![“But might not his [the president's] nomination be overruled? I grant it might, yet this could only be to make place for another nomination by himself. The person ultimately appointed must be object of his preference, though perhaps not in the first degree. It is also not very probable that his…” quote by Alexander Hamilton](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/ff4/alexander-hamilton-619_degrees_but-might-not-his-the-president-s-nomina_2431678.jpg)
![“The [President's] Nomination, of Course, brings the Subject fully under the Consideration of the Senate; who have then a Right to decide upon its Propriety or Impropriety.” quote by George Mason](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/cd0/george-mason-8435_consideration_the-president-s-nomination-of-course-bri_3180018.jpg)
![“We must use a judicial, rather than a political, standard to evaluate [a nominee's] fitness for the Supreme Court. That standard must be based on the fundamental principle that judges interpret and apply but do not make law.” quote by Orrin Hatch](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/d8b/orrin-hatch-8786_court_we-must-use-a-judicial-rather-than-a-pol_2567435.jpg)
![“While the president is to nominate that individual [to Supreme Court], we in the Senate must provide our advice and consent. This function is not well-defined. The Constitution does not set down a road map. It does not require hearings. In fact, it does not even require questioning on your…” quote by Mike DeWine](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/4aa/mike-dewine-11601_advice_while-the-president-is-to-nominate-that_2442371.jpg)
