Skip to content

Cosmology Quote by R. Joseph Hoffmann

“For modern cosmology God cannot be a working hypothesis because God is not given to us in the observable nature of things. The poetic and theological idea that the universe is an expression of God's creative power is false. And yet the possibility that underlying the nature of things is an…” quote by R. Joseph Hoffmann
Download Open image
““For modern cosmology God cannot be a working hypothesis because God is not given to us in the observable nature of things. The poetic and theological idea that the universe is an expression of God's creative power is false. And yet the possibility that underlying the nature of things is an undiscoverable force of unimaginable simplicity that one may call God haunts and frustrates modern science. If this principle exists, then it cannot be different from our experience of it: it must be inherent, not transcendent; purely natural, therefore, not a violation of its own being, and hence intelligent, in the sense it requires coherence rather than chaos and confusion to exist at all--as the ancient myths tell us; impersonal to the extent that we cannot attribute moral purposes or even will, classically understood, to what we can observe of its operations. It is entirely coextensive and if it has a limit coterminous with what is--a perception that dates in theology from Anselm to Tillich and in natural philosophy from Democritus to Planck. It does not exist in gaps of undiscovered data or models or as an unsolved mystery but in the givenness of the world and the intelligent life form that has arisen to ponder it.””

R. Joseph Hoffmann

About This Quote

Source Essay: “The Limits of Theological Explanation in Cosmology”, 2020

God as a concept may be an inherent, natural principle, not a transcendent being, aligning with scientific coherence.

In simple terms: God could be a natural, simple force, not a supernatural mystery.

Key Takeaway

Consider natural explanations before supernatural ones.

Themes

theology science philosophy

Mood

skeptical inquisitive

Type

philosophical critical.

When to use this quote

  • academic debate
  • public policy
  • personal belief formation

Key Concepts

metaphysics cosmology naturalism

Questions to Reflect On

  • What does “God” represent for you?
  • Can science fully explain existence?
A Different Perspective

Natural explanations may not satisfy existential yearning.

2.4 out of 5 (8 ratings)

More by R. Joseph Hoffmann

Explore all 8 R. Joseph Hoffmann quotes

More Cosmology quotes

Browse all 290 Cosmology quotes