9-11 Quote by Preston Wagner
““Yes, angels exist. Many people say that ‘a loving God would never allow 9/11 to happen, or a really bad car crash, or starvation.’ Yet they neglect the fact that there were survivors of 9/11, the car crash wasn’t fatal, and those who starved at least had a life to live; Interestingly enough, most people who say the former neglect to mention the horror of abortion. Those babies only lived a few months.””
About This Quote
The quote argues that if a benevolent deity exists, suffering events like 9/11, car crashes, or starvation are permissible because survivors exist, and it points out a perceived inconsistency in moral arguments about abortion.
In simple terms: It highlights a perceived double standard in discussions of divine goodness and human suffering.
Key Takeaway
Consider the consistency of your moral reasoning.
Themes
theology
ethics
double standards
Mood
thoughtful
critical
Type
philosophical
controversial
When to use this quote
- debates on the existence of God
- discussions of tragedy
- abortion ethics
- philosophical dialogues
Key Concepts
divine benevolence
human suffering
moral consistency
Questions to Reflect On
- Do you see a logical link between survivorship and divine goodness?
- How do you reconcile suffering with belief in a loving deity?
A Different Perspective
Some may argue that survivorship does not justify suffering, and the analogy may oversimplify complex moral issues.
