Quote by Peter Linebaugh
““Female prophecy must be situated in the crisis of reproduction in the middle of the seventeenth century. This was the peak period for the criminalization of women in England and throughout Europe, as prosecutions for infanticide, abortion, and witchcraft reached their highest rate. It was also the period in which men began to wrest control of reproduction from women (male midwives appeared in 1625 and forceps soon thereafter); previously, "childbirth and the lying-in period were a kind of ritual collectively staged and controlled by women, from which men were usually excluded." Since the ruling class had begun to recognize its interest in increased fecundity, "attention was focussed on the 'population' as fundamental category for economic and political analysis." The simultaneous births of modern obstetrics and modern demography were responses to this crisis. Both, like the witchcraft prosecutions, sought to rationalize social reproduction in a capitalist context - that is, as the breeding of labor power. A recurring motif in the ruling-class imagination was intercourse between the English witch and the "black man" - a devil or imp. The terror was not limited to an imaginary chamber of horrors; it was an actuality of counterevolution.””
About This Quote
Source Book: The Rise of the Global Economy, 1500-1820, Peter Linebaugh, 2015
The quote links 17th‑century reproductive crises, criminalization of women, and the emergence of obstetrics and demography as tools to control labor supply for capitalism.
In simple terms: Historical control of women's bodies turned into economic policy.
Recognize how demographic policies can mask power dynamics.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- policy analysis
- gender studies
- public health
- labor economics
- historical research
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How did women navigate or resist these reproductive controls?
- What modern policies echo these historic power shifts?
The analysis may overlook agency of women resisting these controls.