Puerto rico Quote by Nelson A. Denis
““When you consider, Mr. Speaker, that these gentlemen are sent there to make laws for a country they do not know, for a people whose laws, customs, and language they do not know . . . you may imagine, Mr. Speaker, the probability of their doing well.1 —FEDERICO DEGATAU, the first resident commissioner from Puerto Rico, speaking to the US Congress in 1899 The””
About This Quote
Source Speech: US Congressional Record, 1899, Rico Rico Resident Commissioner Federico De Gataú
The speaker warns that lawmakers unfamiliar with a nation's culture, language, and customs are unlikely to create effective legislation.
In simple terms: Unfamiliar lawmakers struggle to make good laws.
Key Takeaway
Ensure representatives truly understand the people they serve.
Themes
representation
lawmaking
cultural competence
Mood
critical
concerned
Type
political
analytical
When to use this quote
- policy drafting
- international aid
- community outreach
- legislative reform
Key Concepts
political legitimacy
local knowledge
Questions to Reflect On
- How can legislators gain authentic insight into distant communities?
- What mechanisms ensure laws respect local customs?
A Different Perspective
If representatives are distant, they may still succeed with strong research teams.
![“Mr. Speaker, I am sure the picture of the hon. member of the NDP [Svend Robinson] is posted in much more wonderful places than just police stations.” quote by Stephen Harper](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/60d/stephen-harper-3432_members_mr-speaker-i-am-sure-the-picture-of-the_1004873.jpg)
