Historians Quote by Markham Shaw Pyle
““Recent fads in history and biography have increasingly exalted the aridity of chronology and fact, and have, with some valid reason, rejected romanticizing and the presumption of guessing at the inner thoughts of historical figures. Unfortunately, the result has largely been not to demythologize the past, but merely to dehumanize and depersonalize it. As Roger Mudd has pointed out, 'Too many of today's historians [and biographers] ... seem to have forgotten that the writing of history is a literary art.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: The Historian’s Dilemma, 2020
Historians focusing only on facts risk stripping humanity from the past, turning people into mere data points.
In simple terms: Fact‑only history can dehumanize subjects.
Key Takeaway
Balance factual rigor with narrative empathy.
Themes
history
humanity
literary art
biography
Mood
reflective
critical
Type
analytical
philosophical
When to use this quote
- Academic writing
- museum exhibits
- documentary filmmaking
Key Concepts
Narrative empathy
historical methodology
literary criticism
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we honor truth while preserving humanity?
- What narrative techniques humanize historical figures?
A Different Perspective
Overemphasis on facts may still miss emotional truth.
![“Certainly professionally, yes [I was interested more in history]. And literary criticism, the structure of poetry. But it is primarily as a historian that I work, although text criticism and literary criticism are very much a part of my interests.” quote by Frank Moore Cross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/b7f/frank-moore-cross-14963_criticism_certainly-professionally-yes-i-was-inter_3110471.jpg)
![“... in 1912, although he, more even than other members of the Senate and the House, thought himself presidential timber (a delusion from which vanishingly few senators and representatives are wholly free when they gaze enraptured into their mirrors of a morning), Senator [William Alden] Smith…” quote by Markham Shaw Pyle](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/d6b/markham-shaw-pyle-22408_congress_in-1912-although-he-more-even-than-other_191616.jpg)
![“Show me you care about our common tongue. Bring to your [writing] passion, deeply informed by knowledge of your subject. Stay me, not with apples and flagons, but with wit and grace, humor and intense caring about your discipline. Don't slack, don't give it a lick and a promise, don't make it…” quote by Markham Shaw Pyle](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/9ec/markham-shaw-pyle-22408_authors_show-me-you-care-about-our-common-tongue_515202.jpg)
![“I have learned more [from Balzac] than from all the professional historians, economists, and statisticians put together.” quote by Friedrich Engels](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/22f/friedrich-engels-8301_balzac_i-have-learned-more-from-balzac-than-fro_62197.jpg)
