Skip to content

Best Quote by Lionel Shriver

“As individuals are best off believing they control their behaviour, the judiciary is best off imputing that control - barring powerful extenuating factors such as mental illness.” quote by Lionel Shriver
Download Open image
“As individuals are best off believing they control their behaviour, the judiciary is best off imputing that control - barring powerful extenuating factors such as mental illness.”

Lionel Shriver

About This Quote

Source Article: Legal Theory, 2018

People overestimate personal control, while courts assume control, ignoring mental illness and other mitigating factors.

In simple terms: We think we control behavior, but law often assumes it, missing mental health issues.

Key Takeaway

Consider mental health when attributing responsibility.

Themes

control law mental health responsibility

Mood

critical analytical thought‑provoking

Type

academic philosophical

When to use this quote

  • court sentencing
  • policy reform
  • psychological assessment
  • public discourse

Key Concepts

jurisprudence psychology ethics social policy

Questions to Reflect On

  • How should law balance personal agency with mental illness?
  • What safeguards protect against unjust imputations?
A Different Perspective

May oversimplify legal complexities.

3.5 out of 5 (9 ratings)

More by Lionel Shriver

Explore all 375 Lionel Shriver quotes

More Best quotes

Browse all 21,675 Best quotes