Pledge Quote by Kyle MacDonald
“Obviously I was never a Girl Guide and only a scout for a short time never did like camping! however listening to the new Scout pledge since their leaders have changed it; I found disgusting. It used to say I will do my duty to serve God and the Queen and my Country? Now it does not mention God anymore since we have to think of other religion's of which are many that have come to settle in the United Kingdom. It annoys me since they wanted to come here why must we tolerate their cultures shouldn't they accept and get used to ours?”
About This Quote
Source Scouting: Scout Promise and Law, United Kingdom, 2023
The author laments changes to the Scout pledge that removed references to God, viewing it as cultural erosion and questioning tolerance of other religions.
In simple terms: Changes to a pledge cause discomfort about cultural identity.
Key Takeaway
Consider how inclusivity impacts tradition.
Themes
tradition
identity
inclusivity
religion
culture
Mood
frustrated
concerned
Type
reflective
critical
When to use this quote
- youth organizations
- community events
- interfaith dialogues
Key Concepts
secularism
social cohesion
pluralism
Questions to Reflect On
- How should institutions adapt to multicultural societies?
- What values should remain unchanged?
A Different Perspective
Balancing respect for tradition with diverse beliefs can be challenging.
