Body of christ Quote by Joseph Pohle
““bread and wine." These species must, therefore, be acci dents, and, having by Transubstantiation lost their con natural subjects, which cannot be supplied by the Body of Christ, they are clearly accidentia sine subiecto.””
About This Quote
Source Treatise: Theologia Scholastica, 17th century
The quote argues that after transubstantiation the bread and wine retain only accidental qualities, lacking their natural substance, which cannot be provided by Christ’s body.
In simple terms: Bread and wine lose their substance, keeping only accidents.
Key Takeaway
Recognize the theological distinction between substance and accidents.
Themes
theology
philosophy
sacraments
Mood
reflective
analytical
Type
theological
academic
When to use this quote
- church liturgy
- academic debate
- religious education
- ecumenical dialogue
Key Concepts
substance theory
accident theory
transubstantiation
Questions to Reflect On
- How does this view affect Eucharistic practice?
- Do other traditions share this metaphysical framework?
A Different Perspective
The claim depends on specific metaphysical assumptions not universally accepted.
![“St. Bruno of Asti, who says: " The first tabernacle, therefore, is the Synagogue; the second, the Church; the third, Heaven. . . . The first was in a shadow and an image, the second is in an image and in truth, and the third [will be] in the truth alone. In the first, life is foreshadowed; in the…” quote by Joseph Pohle](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/7d8/joseph-pohle-3769_life_st-bruno-of-asti-who-says-the-first-tabe_36723.jpg)
