Skip to content

Class struggle Quote by Joseph Alois Schumpeter

“The exaggeration of the definiteness and importance of the dividing line between the capitalist class in that sense and the proletariat was surpassed only by the exaggeration of the antagonism between them. To any mind not warped by the habit of fingering the Marxian rosary it should be obvious…” quote by Joseph Alois Schumpeter
Download Open image
““The exaggeration of the definiteness and importance of the dividing line between the capitalist class in that sense and the proletariat was surpassed only by the exaggeration of the antagonism between them. To any mind not warped by the habit of fingering the Marxian rosary it should be obvious that their relation is, in normal times, primarily one of cooperation and that any theory to the contrary must draw largely on pathological cases for verification. In social life, antagonism and synagogism are of course both ubiquitous and in fact inseparable except in the rarest of cases. But I am almost tempted to say that there was, if anything, less of absolute nonsense in the old harmonistic view—full of nonsense though that was too—than in the Marxian construction of the impassable gulf between tool owners and tool users. Again, however, he had no choice, not because he wanted to arrive at revolutionary results—these he could have derived just as well from dozens of other possible schemata—but because of the requirements of his own analysis. If class struggle was the subject matter of history and also the means of bringing about the socialist dawn, and if there had to be just those two classes, then their relation had to be antagonistic on principle or else the force in his system of social dynamics would have been lost.””

Joseph Alois Schumpeter

About This Quote

Source Book: Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, 1942

Class relations are often portrayed as antagonistic, yet they cooperate in normal times; extreme conflict is rare.

In simple terms: Classes cooperate more than they fight.

Key Takeaway

Balance cooperation with awareness of conflict.

Themes

economics class relations marxism cooperation conflict

Mood

critical thoughtful

Type

theoretical analytical

When to use this quote

  • policy making
  • labor negotiations
  • economic forecasting
  • academic debate

Key Concepts

dialectical materialism social theory

Questions to Reflect On

  • What evidence shows cooperation between classes?
  • When does antagonism become dominant?
A Different Perspective

Overemphasizes cooperation may downplay genuine exploitation.

3.6 out of 5 (6 ratings)

More by Joseph Alois Schumpeter

Explore all 3 Joseph Alois Schumpeter quotes

More Class struggle quotes

Browse all 152 Class struggle quotes