Brothers and sisters Quote by James Boswell
““Mr. Langton one day asked him [Samuel Johnson] how he had acquired so accurate a knowledge of Latin, in which, I believe, he was exceeded by no man of his time; he said, 'My master whipt me very well. Without that, Sir, I should have done nothing.' He told Mr. Langton, that while Hunter was flogging his boys unmercifully, he used to say, 'And this I do to save you from the gallows.' Johnson, upon all occasions, expressed his approbation of enforcing instruction by means of the rod. 'I would rather (said he) have the rod to be the general terrour to all, to make them learn, than tell a child, if you do thus, or thus, you will be more esteemed than your brothers or sisters. The rod produces an effect which terminates in itself. A child is afraid of being whipped, and gets his task, and there's an end on't; whereas, by exciting emulation and comparisons of superiority, you lay the foundation of lasting mischief; you make brothers and sisters hate each other.””
About This Quote
Source Book: Life of Samuel Johnson by James Boswell, 1791
Johnson argues that fear-based discipline (the rod) is more effective than competition or praise for motivating children, as it avoids fostering rivalry and resentment.
In simple terms: Fearful punishment works better than rivalry for learning.
Use clear, consistent expectations rather than harsh punishment.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- parenting
- classroom management
- team leadership
- sports coaching
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we motivate without fear?
- What alternatives foster healthy competition?
Harsh punishment can cause trauma and damage trust.