Empty places Quote by J. Christopher Herold
““Greatness has its beauties, but only in retrospect and in the imagination": thus wrote General Bonaparte to General Moreau in 1800. His observation helps to explain why the world, only a few years after sighing with relief at its delivery from the ogre, began to worship him as the greatest man of modern times. Napoleon had barely left the scene when the fifteen years that he had carved out of world history to create his glory seemed scarcely believable. Only the scars of the war veterans and the empty places in the widows' beds seemed to attest to the reality of those years, and time soon eliminated even these silent witnesses. What remained, in retrospect and in the imagination, was legend and symbol.””
About This Quote
Source Book: Napoleon: The Man and the Myth, 1970
Historical figures become legends when memory reshapes reality, blending fact and imagination.
In simple terms: History turns people into myths.
Key Takeaway
Recognize myth vs. fact.
Themes
history
memory
mythmaking
Mood
critical
thoughtful
Type
historical
analytical
When to use this quote
- education
- media analysis
- political rhetoric
- cultural studies
Key Concepts
historical narrative
collective memory
Questions to Reflect On
- What narratives shape our view of leaders?
- How does imagination alter historical truth?
A Different Perspective
Myths can obscure accountability.
![“The popular image [in England] of Bonaparte as a blood-stained tyrant and bandit was admittedly exaggerated, but instinct told even the most radical among the English that if liberty, equality, and justice were ever to come to their shores, it certainly was not Napoleon who would bring them there.” quote by J. Christopher Herold](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/dfc/j-christopher-herold-30177_freedom_the-popular-image-in-england-of-bonapart_1033829.jpg)
![“His [Pitt's] successor as prime minister was Mr. Addington, who was a friend of Mr. Pitt, just as Mr. Pitt was a friend of Mr. Addington; but their respective friends were each other's enemies. Mr. Fox, who was Mr. Pitt's enemy (although many of his friends were Mr. Pitt's friends), had always…” quote by J. Christopher Herold](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/b4a/j-christopher-herold-30177_effort_his-pitt-s-successor-as-prime-minister-w_1080769.jpg)
