Skip to content

Gone forever Quote by Ignacio De Loyola Brandao

“The photo was published in the majority of Brazilian newspapers in a full-page spread when CNN and all the television channels of the world broadcast the scene, they froze it for a few seconds. Or minutes, hours, I don't know. For me time has infinite duration--I don't know how to measure it by…” quote by Ignacio De Loyola Brandao
Download Open image
““The photo was published in the majority of Brazilian newspapers in a full-page spread when CNN and all the television channels of the world broadcast the scene, they froze it for a few seconds. Or minutes, hours, I don't know. For me time has infinite duration--I don't know how to measure it by normal parameters. Trying doesn't even interest me. From the World Trade Center buildings, minutes, prior to their collapse--which would appear as a perfect and planned implosion--only a grayish-blue and black vertical lines can be seen. Like a modernist painting--by whom? Which artist painted lines? Mondrian? No, not Mondrian, he painted squares, rectangles. Anyway, in the picture, the man is falling head first. his body straight, one of his legs bent. Did he jump? Slip? Did he faint and then fall? He probably lost consciousness because of the height, the smoke. He fell. He disappeared from the scene, from life, from the city. A million tons of rubble buried him soon after. Nobody knows his name. Impossible for his family to have him identified. He's an unknown who entered into history at the twenty-first century's first great moment of horror--the history of the world, the United States, communications, photography. Without anyone knowing who he is. And nobody will ever know. We'll only have suppositions, families who'll swear that he was theirs. But was he Brazilian, American, Latino, Chinese, Italian, Irish--what? He could have been anything, but now he's nothing. One among thousands gone forever. And, while we're on the subject, what about the firemen who supposedly became such heroes that day--can you name a single one?””

Ignacio De Loyola Brandao

About This Quote

Source Interview: Personal reflection on 9/11 imagery, null

The narrator describes a frozen, timeless moment of a falling man during 9/11, questioning identity and the anonymity of tragedy.

In simple terms: A man fell during 9/11, his identity lost, leaving only images.

Key Takeaway

Remember the human stories behind iconic images.

Themes

history media anonymity

Mood

somber thoughtful

Type

reflective critical

When to use this quote

  • journalism
  • memorials
  • education

Key Concepts

memory visual culture trauma

Questions to Reflect On

  • What responsibilities do media have in portraying tragedy?
  • How does anonymity affect collective mourning?
A Different Perspective

The image can desensitize or dehumanize victims.

4.2 out of 5 (10 ratings)

More by Ignacio De Loyola Brandao

Explore all 5 Ignacio De Loyola Brandao quotes

More Gone forever quotes

Browse all 336 Gone forever quotes