Skip to content

Crime Quote by Ibrahim al-Koni

“Answer this question for me now: When does the Law authorize punishment?” Without any hesitation the diviner replied, “When there’s evidence!” “Evidence?” Yazzal did not respond, and so Ewar said menacingly, “But where’s the evidence? There’s no clear-cut evidence anywhere in our world.” “Here…” quote by Ibrahim al-Koni
Download Open image
““Answer this question for me now: When does the Law authorize punishment?” Without any hesitation the diviner replied, “When there’s evidence!” “Evidence?” Yazzal did not respond, and so Ewar said menacingly, “But where’s the evidence? There’s no clear-cut evidence anywhere in our world.” “Here, you’ve answered the question.” “What do you mean?” “I mean that the difficulty of rendering a verdict against someone arises from the difficulty of obtaining clear-cut evidence.” “But evil-doers will ruin the earth and turn upside down the lives of oppressed people without our being able to pinpoint the truth of what you call ‘evidence’ and I term ‘slander’.” “Do you know why? It’s because the Law knows that there is nothing in the created world more difficult than passing judgment on a man for an offense.” “Is that because we all commit offenses?” “I don’t know, but generations have learned from trial and error that it is the lesser of two evils for the masses to experience injustice than for one man to be wrongly convicted.” “I bet this is, in and of itself, a scourge. I bet this is what the tribes call a calamity.” “We are not heroic when we punish. We are heroic when we forgive. That’s what the Law says.” Ewar swayed to the right and left and repeated, as if wailing a lament, “The Law, the Law; how inhumane are the commandments of the Law!””

Ibrahim al-Koni

About This Quote

Source Novel: The Law of the Land, 1998

Law struggles with clear evidence, making punishment difficult; forgiveness is the higher virtue.

In simple terms: Law needs evidence, but forgiveness is heroic.

Key Takeaway

Prioritize justice and forgiveness.

Themes

justice evidence forgiveness law morality

Mood

thoughtful somber

Type

philosophical inspirational

When to use this quote

  • courtroom decisions
  • conflict resolution
  • community healing
  • policy making

Key Concepts

epistemology ethical dilemmas social order

Questions to Reflect On

  • When should mercy outweigh strict law?
  • How can societies improve evidentiary standards?
A Different Perspective

Evidence is often ambiguous, leading to wrongful convictions.

2.4 out of 5 (6 ratings)

More by Ibrahim al-Koni

Explore all 15 Ibrahim al-Koni quotes

More Crime quotes

Browse all 8,359 Crime quotes