Confidence Quote by Erik Larson
““The Chancellor’s assurances were so satisfying and so unexpected that I think they are on the whole too good to be true,” Messersmith wrote. “We must keep in mind, I believe, that when Hitler says anything he for the moment convinces himself that it is true. He is basically sincere; but he is at the same time a fanatic.” Messersmith urged skepticism regarding Hitler’s protestations. “I think for the moment he genuinely desires peace but it is a peace of his own kind and with an armed force constantly becoming more effective in reserve, in order to impose their will when it may become essential.” He reiterated his belief that Hitler’s government could not be viewed as a rational entity. “There are so many pathological cases involved that it would be impossible to tell from day to day what will happen any more than the keeper of a madhouse is able to tell what his inmates will do in the next hour or during the next day.” He urged caution, in effect warning Phillips to be skeptical of Dodd’s conviction that Hitler wanted peace. “I think for the present moment … we must guard against any undue optimism which may be aroused by the apparently satisfying declarations of the Chancellor.””
About This Quote
Source Book: The Splendid and the Vile by Erik Larson, 2020
Messersmith warns that Hitler’s statements of peace are deceptive, driven by fanaticism and strategic deception, urging skepticism and caution against false optimism.
In simple terms: Hitler’s peace promises are likely a façade; be wary.
Questionly, question claims.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- diplomatic negotiations
- public speeches
- media analysis
- policy making
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can leaders discern genuine intent from strategic deception?
- What safeguards prevent optimism from blinding policy?
Hitler’s rhetoric could be genuine in moments, making absolute judgment difficult.