Alma-whittaker Quote by Elizabeth Gilbert
““Boehme makes such leaps, such contradictions, such confusions of thought. It is as though he wishes to vault directly into heaven upon the strength of his logic, but his logic is deeply impaired." She reached across the table for a book and flung it open. "In this chapter here, for instance, he is trying to find keys to God's secrets hidden inside the plants of the Bible- but what are we to make of it, when his information is simply incorrect? He spends a full chapter interpreting 'the lilies of the field' as mentioned in the book of Matthew, dissecting every letter of the word 'lilies,' looking for revelation within the syllables... but Ambrose, 'the lilies of the field' itself is a mistranslation. It would not have 'been' lilies that Christ discussed in his Sermon on the Mount. There are only two varieties of lily native to Palestine, and both are exceedingly rare. They would not have flowered in such abundance as to have ever filled a meadow. They would not have been familiar enough to the common man. Christ, tailoring his lesson to the widest possible audience, would more likely have referred to a ubiquitous flower, in order that his listeners would comprehend his metaphor. For that reason, it is exceedingly probable that Christ was talking about the anemones of the field- probably 'Anemone coronaria'- though we cannot be certain...””
About This Quote
Source Book: The Signature of All Things by Elizabeth Gilbert, 2013
The passage critiques over‑interpretation of religious texts, warning that forcing meaning onto ambiguous symbols can lead to false conclusions.
In simple terms: Over‑interpretation can mislead truth seeking.
Check sources before drawing conclusions.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- theological study
- biblical scholarship
- literary analysis
- academic research
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- What evidence supports a symbolic claim?
- How can we balance faith and scholarly rigor?
Literal readings may ignore cultural and historical context.