Argument Quote by David Potter
““There is a presumption in favor of every existing institution. Many of these (we will suppose the majority) may be susceptible of alteration for the better; but still the "Burden of proof" lies with him who proposes an alteration; simply, on the ground that since a change is not a good in itself, he who demands a change should show cause for it. No one is called on . . . to defend an existing institution, till some argument is adduced against it; and that argument ought in fairness to prove, not merely an actual inconvenience, but the possibility of a change for the better.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: The Burden of Proof in Institutional Change, 19th century political commentary
Institutions are presumed valid; challengers must prove a change improves things, not just inconveniences.
In simple terms: Changing institutions requires proof of benefit.
Key Takeaway
Provide evidence of improvement before demanding change.
Themes
conservatism
reform
burden of proof
Mood
critical
analytical
Type
philosophical
political
When to use this quote
- legislative reform
- organizational restructuring
- social movements
- academic debates
Key Concepts
institutional inertia
rational discourse
policy change
Questions to Reflect On
- What evidence would convince you a change is beneficial?
- How do power dynamics affect the burden of proof?
A Different Perspective
Proving benefit can be subjective and politically contested.
![“A presumption becomes a self-refuting assertion". ~R. Alan Woods [2012]” quote by R. Alan Woods](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/5b2/r-alan-woods-1455_assertions_a-presumption-becomes-a-self-refuting-as_1929262.jpg)
