Skip to content

Dissent Quote by Christopher Hitchens

“Not long ago, having expressed some disagreements in print with an old comrade of long standing, I was sent a response that he had published in an obscure newspaper. This riposte referred to my opinions as ‘racist.’ I would obviously scorn to deny such an allegation on my own behalf. I would…” quote by Christopher Hitchens
Download Open image
““Not long ago, having expressed some disagreements in print with an old comrade of long standing, I was sent a response that he had published in an obscure newspaper. This riposte referred to my opinions as ‘racist.’ I would obviously scorn to deny such an allegation on my own behalf. I would, rather, prefer to repudiate it on behalf of my former friend. He had known me for many years and cooperated with me on numerous projects, and I am quite confident that he would never have as a collaborator anyone he suspected of racial prejudice. But it does remind me, and not for the first time, that quarrels on the left have a tendency to become miniature treason trials, replete with all kinds of denunciation. There's a general tendency—not by any means confined to radicals but in some way specially associated with them—to believe that once the lowest motive for a dissenting position has been found, it must in some way be the real one.””

Christopher Hitchens

About This Quote

Source Essay: “The Left and the Treason Trials” (published in a literary magazine, 2005)

The author observes that left‑wing disputes often devolve into moral witch‑hunts, where any hint of a questionable motive is treated as definitive proof of bad intent.

In simple terms: Leftist debates can become accusations of treason based on minimal evidence.

Key Takeaway

Beware of reducing complex disagreements to single motives.

Themes

politics ideology conflict ethics discourse

Mood

critical reflective

Type

analytical philosophical

When to use this quote

  • academic debates
  • online forums
  • political activism
  • media commentary

Key Concepts

moral panic group dynamics confirmation bias

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can we foster constructive criticism without resorting to moralizing?
  • What safeguards prevent ideological purity tests?
A Different Perspective

Such accusations can silence dissent and damage relationships.

5.0 out of 5 (10 ratings)

More by Christopher Hitchens

Explore all 1,241 Christopher Hitchens quotes

More Dissent quotes

Browse all 440 Dissent quotes