Book Quote by Chris Hayes
“Generally the impulse to find justice through punitive measures can be a kind of quicksand. What James Whitman, the scholar I cite in the chapter of my book, talks about as an urge to level down, I think you see that everywhere. We're going to be a punitive society, so we might as well level out that punitiveness. Bankers and college swim stars and everyone face that same kind of wrath.”
About This Quote
Source Book: The New Jim Crow, 2010 (reference)
Punitive impulses can become self‑reinforcing, leading societies to over‑penalize and perpetuate cycles of resentment.
In simple terms: Harsh punishments can trap societies in endless retaliation.
Key Takeaway
Seek restorative alternatives.
Themes
justice
punishment
societal cycles
Mood
reflective
concerned
Type
political
social
When to use this quote
- criminal justice reform
- corporate regulation
- educational discipline
- public policy debates
Key Concepts
penology
social control
restorative justice
Questions to Reflect On
- What are the long‑term effects of punitive policies?
- How might restorative approaches change outcomes?
A Different Perspective
Punishment may not address underlying issues and can cause collateral damage.
![“Some [intentional communities], like the Shakers and the Harmony Society, have endured for a century or even longer. The Hutterians, to cite an extreme example, are today still strongly committed to communal living after practicing it, punctuated only by occasional lapses into private enterprise…” quote by Benjamin Zablocki](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/3ac/benjamin-zablocki-164471_business_some-intentional-communities-like-the-sh_110542.jpg)
![“Ted Cruz who's been gaining on [Donald] Trump in Iowa and is polling ahead of him in the latest Monmouth poll would be quite reluctant to criticize Trump's plan saying simply it is not his policy.” quote by Chris Hayes](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/be8/chris-hayes-2208_criticize_ted-cruz-who-s-been-gaining-on-donald-tr_39854.jpg)
![“Now, [Donald] Trump has thus far gotten endorsements from illustrious group, that includes Sarah Palin, David Duke, Dennis Rodman, racially profiling birther sheriff, Joe Arpaio, vaping Congressman Duncan Hunter, and just this afternoon, infamous Maine Governor Paul LePage who accused drug dealers…” quote by Chris Hayes](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/19c/chris-hayes-2208_accused_now-donald-trump-has-thus-far-gotten-end_117408.jpg)
![“The [Donald's] Trump war on the press continues. Tonight, the national cost of a conservative media bubble, now featuring alien conspiracy theories. And about those Obamacare headlines.” quote by Chris Hayes](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/485/chris-hayes-2208_aliens_the-donald-s-trump-war-on-the-press-cont_260339.jpg)
