Existence of god Quote by Charles Bufe
““As well, the very religiosity of step 2 is a major problem for many persons. Like steps 3, 5, 6, 7 and 11, step 2 refers to “God,” “Him,” or “a Power greater than ourselves.” (Note the capitalization.) This poses obvious problems for those who believe that the existence of God is no more likely than the existence of Mother Goose.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: The Problem of God in Secular Thought, Charles Bufe, 2005
Referencing God in step‑based programs can alienate non‑theistic participants, creating barriers to engagement.
In simple terms: Mentioning God may exclude non‑believers.
Key Takeaway
Design inclusive frameworks that avoid exclusive religious language.
Themes
inclusion
secularism
psychology
program design
Mood
thoughtful
neutral
Type
practical
inclusive
When to use this quote
- self‑help workshops
- educational curricula
- team building sessions
Key Concepts
Secular ethics
motivation
group dynamics
Questions to Reflect On
- How can programs respect both believers and non‑believers?
- What alternative language maintains purpose without alienation?
A Different Perspective
May dilute spiritual depth for believers.
![“As Jack Trimpey, founder of Rational Recovery, has pointed out, steps 2 and 3 are a con—a classic “bait and switch.” Specifically, step 3 poses obvious problems for atheist and agnostic newcomers who have chosen, for example, a doorknob as their “Power greater than [themselves].” How does one turn…” quote by Charles Bufe](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/2b9/charles-bufe-40675_quote_as-jack-trimpey-founder-of-rational-reco_1278748.jpg)
![“Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character. This is yet another step which invokes “God” and encourages dependence rather than independence. It echoes the first three steps’ declarations of personal “powerlessness” (first step), personal “[in]sanity” (second step), and…” quote by Charles Bufe](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/84d/charles-bufe-40675_first-step_were-entirely-ready-to-have-god-remove-a_2096373.jpg)
