Miracles Quote by Benjamin Blech
““Here is a fundamental distinction between Judaism and Christianity. The Gospels record the miracles performed by Jesus at length, and miracles play an extremely significant role in Christianity. The wondrous acts of Jesus, such as reviving the dead, healing the incurable, and transforming water into wine, are meant to serve as cogent evidence not only of his divine authorization but of his divinity. The virgin birth and the resurrection are not only major events but also fundamental articles of belief; this, despite the specific warning in Deuteronomy that "if there arise in your midst a prophet or a dreamer of dreams, and he gives you a sign or a wonder" and that sign or wonder is used as a rationale for rejecting any part of the Torah, then the "miracle" must clearly be rejected. In Christianity, miracles were sufficient to warrant the replacement of the Old Testament by the New, the message of Moses to be superseded by that of Jesus.””
About This Quote
Source Book: The Complete Idiot's Guide to Understanding Judaism, 2005
The quote contrasts how Judaism and Christianity view miracles, emphasizing that Christianity uses miracles as proof of Jesus’ divinity, while Judaism is wary of such signs as potentially misleading.
In simple terms: Christianity sees miracles as proof of Jesus; Judaism is cautious about signs.
Key Takeaway
Recognize differing theological roles of miracles.
Themes
theology
interfaith
belief
miracles
authority
Mood
thoughtful
analytical
Type
theoretical
comparative
When to use this quote
- religious education
- interfaith dialogue
- personal belief assessment
- academic study of religion
Key Concepts
Divine authority
scriptural interpretation
faith traditions
Questions to Reflect On
- How do miracles shape faith identity?
- What criteria determine a sign's legitimacy?
A Different Perspective
Judaism may reject miracles that conflict with Torah warnings.
